Hybrid Mortgages: Splitting Between Fixed and Variable

by Silvana Azurdia

A hybrid mortgage, also called a combination mortgage, splits what you borrow: part at a fixed rate and part at a variable rate, sometimes with different terms. This guide is for buyers and owners weighing fixed against variable: how payments, prepayments and penalties work on each part, why some borrowers split, the trade-offs, an example with the numbers, and what to ask a lender or broker.

The short version

 

A hybrid mortgage puts part of your balance at a fixed rate and the rest at a variable rate. The fixed part gives you partial protection if rates rise, and the variable part a partial benefit if they fall. Each part has its own rate and payment, and generally its own penalty: on the fixed part, usually the higher of three months' interest or the interest rate differential; on the variable part, usually three months' interest. The parts can have different terms, which staggers your renewals but can make it harder to move to another lender, and some lenders register a plan with several parts as a collateral charge. In my example, a $600,000 mortgage split in half sees its payment move about half as much as an all-variable one when rates change.

How a hybrid mortgage works

 

The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) describes a hybrid or combination mortgage as one where part of the mortgage has a fixed interest rate and the other part a variable rate. FCAC notes that the fixed portion offers partial protection if rates go up, the variable portion offers a partial benefit if they fall, and each portion may have different terms.

Lenders' published products set this up in two broad ways:

  • A single split mortgage. One part is a closed fixed-rate mortgage and the other a variable-rate mortgage, and your payment is made up of the two.
  • Parts within a plan. Some lenders let you divide your borrowing into several parts within one plan that can also hold lines of credit. One big bank's plan, for example, allows up to three mortgage parts, each with its own rate type and term.

Each part generally works like a mortgage of its own rate type. For how fixed and variable rates compare on their own, see Fixed or Variable?

Payments on each part

 
  • The fixed part. Its rate, and its share of your payment, stay the same until that part's term ends.
  • The variable part with adjustable payments. Its rate moves with your lender's prime rate, and its share of your payment changes when the rate does.
  • The variable part with fixed payments. The payment stays the same, and the split between interest and principal shifts instead. At a certain rate, called the trigger rate, the payment covers only interest, and above that rate it no longer covers all the interest. I explain how that works in Trigger Rates.

Lenders also calculate interest in different ways. FCAC's sample fixed-rate mortgage disclosure compounds interest twice a year and charges it monthly. For variable rates, some lenders' terms compound monthly and others twice a year, so ask how each part is calculated.

An example: splitting $600,000

 

Here is an example with assumed rates, not anyone's offer. Take a $600,000 mortgage over 25 years, split in half: $300,000 fixed at 4.5% for five years, compounded twice a year, and $300,000 variable at 4% with adjustable payments, assumed to be compounded monthly, at one-twelfth of the annual rate each month.

  • Fixed part: about $1,660 a month for the term.
  • Variable part: about $1,584 a month at 4%.
  • Total: about $3,244, between about $3,321 for an all-fixed mortgage at 4.5% and about $3,167 for an all-variable one at 4%.

Say the variable rate rose 1 point after the first year, and the variable payment was reset over the 24 years left. That part's payment would rise to about $1,748, taking your total to about $3,409, about $165 more. All variable, the payment would rise by about $329, to about $3,496. If the rate fell 1 point instead, the split would save about $156 a month and the all-variable mortgage about $312. Either way, the fixed part's payment stays the same until its term ends.

Prepayments and penalties on each part

 

Each part generally follows the rules for its own rate type, so read the prepayment section for each one.

  • Prepayment privileges. Lenders set their own rules for extra payments without a penalty. One big bank's plan, for example, lets you apply your privileges to whichever part you choose.
  • Breaking the fixed part. Paying it off before its term ends usually costs the higher of three months' interest or the interest rate differential (IRD), which compares your rate with current rates for the time left.
  • Breaking the variable part. Lenders' published terms usually set the penalty at three months' interest.
  • Converting the variable part. Many lenders let you convert a variable rate to a fixed rate during the term, at the fixed rate offered then, if you later want more certainty.

If you sell, each part would be paid out under its own terms unless your lender lets you take the mortgage to your next home. I compare those options in Porting, Blending or Breaking.

Why some borrowers split

 
  • Spreading rate risk. Neither a rise nor a fall in rates affects your whole balance. In the example, a 1-point move changed the split payment by about half as much as the all-variable payment.
  • A payment between the two. When the variable rate starts below the fixed rate, as in the example, the starting payment sits between the all-fixed and all-variable payments.
  • Staggered renewals. If the parts have different terms, they renew at different times, so your whole balance doesn't reset at one rate on one date. I compare term lengths in Choosing a Mortgage Term.

The trade-offs

 
  • More to keep track of. Two rates and two payments, and possibly two sets of prepayment rules, penalties and maturity dates.
  • Harder to switch lenders. FCAC notes that because each portion may have different terms, hybrid mortgages may be harder to transfer to another lender. If one part's term ends while the other still has time left, moving everything at that renewal would mean paying a penalty on the part still in its term, or waiting.
  • How it's registered. Some lenders register a plan with several parts as a collateral charge: a single registration, often for more than you borrow, that can secure other loans with the same lender. Another big bank, for example, typically registers its plan for up to 100% of the home's value. That can make borrowing more later simpler, but many lenders won't accept a transfer of a collateral charge, so moving usually means a discharge and a new registration, with legal and other costs, and the charge is discharged only once every loan it secures is repaid. See Collateral Charge Mortgages.

Questions to ask a lender or broker

 
  • How much can go into each part, and can each part have its own term?
  • Does each part have its own prepayment privileges, or is there one allowance for the whole mortgage?
  • How is the penalty worked out on each part, and can I pay off one part without the other?
  • Can I convert the variable part to a fixed rate, and on what terms?
  • Is the mortgage registered as a standard charge or a collateral charge, and for how much?
  • Can the mortgage be ported, and what happens when each part's term ends?

A mortgage professional can show you the payments at a few different rates and splits before you commit.

Questions buyers often ask me

 

Is a hybrid mortgage the same as a variable rate with fixed payments?

No. With a variable rate and fixed payments, your payment stays the same, but your whole balance is still at a variable rate. A hybrid puts only part of the balance at a variable rate and the rest at a fixed rate.

Do I have to split my mortgage evenly?

Not necessarily. The even split in my example is only an illustration. Lenders set their own rules for how a mortgage can be divided, and some plans allow several parts with different terms and rates, so ask what mix your lender allows.

Can I switch lenders at renewal with a hybrid mortgage?

Yes, if the new lender approves you, but if the parts mature on different dates, moving everything at once means breaking the part still in its term and paying its penalty. A collateral charge can add legal and discharge costs. Ask whether the parts can share a maturity date.

What would it cost to pay off a hybrid mortgage early?

Usually the total of each part's penalty: the higher of three months' interest or the IRD on the fixed part, and usually three months' interest on the variable part. Ask your lender for both figures in writing before you decide.

Can I lock in the variable part later?

Often, yes. Many lenders let you convert a variable rate to a fixed rate during the term, at the fixed rate offered at that time, which may be higher than your variable rate. Check your agreement for conditions, such as a minimum term for the new fixed rate, and any fees.

Weighing your options? Compare the fine print in Comparing Mortgage Offers, read about choosing a mortgage broker or a bank, or try my mortgage calculator.

Thinking about splitting your mortgage?

I would be glad to help you plan your purchase and connect you with mortgage professionals who can show you how a split would work for you. Call or text 778-834-1706, email silvana@silvanaazurdia.ca or send me a message. Happy to help in English or Spanish.

This article is general information, not financial advice. The details come from FCAC and lenders' published mortgage terms and disclosures, and were current at the time of writing; your mortgage agreement sets out how each part of your own mortgage works. For FCAC's guide, see choosing a mortgage that is right for you.

Silvana Azurdia
Silvana Azurdia

Agent BCFSA 166340

+1(778) 834-1706 | silvana@silvanaazurdia.ca

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message