Insured, Insurable and Uninsured Mortgages: Why Your Rate Can Differ

by Silvana Azurdia

Lenders often quote different rates for the same borrower, depending on the down payment, the home's value, the amortization and whether you are buying or refinancing. A common reason is which of three groups the mortgage falls into: insured, insurable or uninsured. If you are comparing offers or coming up for renewal, here is what decides the group, why it changes the price, what happens when you switch or refinance, and what Budget 2026 proposes.

The short version

 

An insured mortgage has less than 20% down and carries mortgage default insurance from CMHC, Sagen or Canada Guaranty, with the premium usually passed on to you. An insurable mortgage has 20% or more down but still meets the insurance rules, including a home worth under $1 million and an amortization of 25 years or less, so your lender can insure it, typically at its own cost. The rest are uninsured, including most refinances and one-unit homes you won't live in. Insurance protects the lender, lowers the capital it must hold and opens government-backed funding, so insured rates can be lower, but count the premium too. A switch at renewal can keep the insurance. Budget 2026 proposes raising the $1 million limit to $1.5 million.

Insured, insurable and uninsured

 

Mortgages fall into three groups, depending on whether they are, or could be, covered by mortgage default insurance. As CMHC points out, that insurance protects the lender, not you.

  • Insured. With less than 20% down, you need it. FCAC lists three insurers: CMHC, Sagen and Canada Guaranty. CMHC says the lender pays the premium and will likely pass it on to you, as a lump sum or added to the mortgage; see Mortgage Default Insurance.
  • Insurable. With 20% or more down, insurance isn't required by law, but the mortgage meets the rules, so your lender can insure it, for example in bulk through what the Department of Finance calls portfolio insurance, which the lender typically pays for.
  • Uninsured. The mortgage doesn't meet the rules, so it can't be insured and the lender carries the whole risk of default.

FCAC adds that a lender may require insurance even with 20% down; if so, ask who pays the premium.

The rules that decide the group

 

The federal regulations and CMHC's rules set the tests:

  • Value. Insured: a home worth less than $1.5 million. Insurable: less than $1 million. At $1.5 million or more, FCAC says you need 20% down.
  • Down payment. Below $1.5 million, the minimum is 5% of the first $500,000 and 10% of the rest.
  • Amortization. Insured: up to 25 years, or 30 if at least one borrower is a first-time buyer or the home is newly built. Insurable: up to 25 years for a purchase, so 30 years with 20% down means uninsured. See choosing 25 or 30 years.
  • Who lives there. Insured: on a home of up to four units, you or a family member related by marriage, common-law partnership or a parent-child relationship must live in one unit. Insurable: that rule applies only to a one-unit home, so a condo bought as a rental is uninsured. Two- to four-unit rentals have their own programs; see Financing a Rental Property.
  • Credit and debt. Generally, at least one borrower or guarantor needs a credit score of 600 or more, and housing costs and total debt payments can't exceed 39% and 44% of gross income, tested at the stress-test rate.
  • Purpose. Buying the home, or moving an existing mortgage to another lender. Taking equity out can't be insured, so a refinance is generally uninsured; CMHC's program for adding a secondary suite is the main exception. See Refinancing Your Mortgage.

Why the group changes your rate

 

The Bank of Canada says funding costs make up most of a mortgage rate, and that because insurance protects the lender from default, you may get a lower rate than on an uninsured mortgage with a bigger down payment. Three things are at work:

  • Less risk. If an insured borrower stops paying, the insurer covers the lender's loss, and the federal government backs the insurance: fully for CMHC, and after a deductible of 10% of the original loan for the private insurers.
  • Less capital. Under OSFI's capital rules, a bank can give a CMHC-insured mortgage, or the government-backed part of a privately insured one, the Government of Canada's risk weight of 0%; an uninsured mortgage is weighted by its loan-to-value ratio. Less capital means lower costs.
  • Cheaper funding. Insured mortgages can be pooled into NHA mortgage-backed securities, whose timely payment CMHC guarantees as an agent of the federal government, and sold, including through the Canada Mortgage Bond program. Every mortgage in a pool must be insured.

A lender can insure an insurable mortgage and fund it the same way; in 2016, the Department of Finance said low-ratio insurance mainly supports lenders' access to these programs. An uninsured mortgage can't use them. Each lender sets its own prices, so ask which group an offer assumes. More in How Fixed Mortgage Rates Are Set.

A bigger down payment or a lower rate: an example

 

Take a $750,000 home and two example rates, chosen only to show the arithmetic: 4.3% for an insured mortgage and 4.5% with 20% down. They aren't quotes, and real gaps vary.

  • 10% down, insured. You put down $75,000 and borrow $675,000. CMHC's premium for a loan of 90% of the price is 3.10%, or $20,925, making the mortgage $695,925 if you add it on. Over 25 years at 4.3%, the payment is about $3,775 a month.
  • 20% down. You put down $150,000 and borrow $600,000, with no premium. Over 25 years at 4.5%, the payment is about $3,321 a month.

FCAC notes that a premium added to the mortgage is charged interest at your mortgage rate. After five years, the insured buyer has paid about $13,500 more in interest, on top of the premium, and owes about $609,000 against about $526,800, while the other buyer put $75,000 more in at the start. On its own, the 0.2-point gap is worth about $66 a month on $600,000. Keeping savings has value too, so ask a mortgage professional to price both with your numbers.

Renewals and switching lenders

 
  • Insurance can move with the mortgage. The regulations allow a new lender's mortgage that pays off an insured one to be insured too, if it meets the original loan's criteria and needs no extra premium. FCAC says borrowing more or extending the amortization when you switch may mean a new premium, and suggests telling the new lender about your existing insurance so you don't pay twice.
  • Insured switches skip the stress test. The Department of Finance says insured borrowers can switch lenders at renewal without another stress test.
  • So can many uninsured ones. Since November 21, 2024, OSFI hasn't expected federally regulated lenders, such as banks, to apply its minimum qualifying rate to a straight switch of an uninsured mortgage between them, with no increase to the loan amount or amortization. Other lenders may set their own rules.
  • Borrowing more is a refinance. It is generally uninsured, and you qualify again, including the stress test.

Ask the new lender which group it will put your mortgage in, and see my post on renewing your mortgage for the rest.

What Budget 2026 proposes

 

Budget 2026, tabled on November 5, 2026, proposes changes that touch these groups, without a start date; the existing rules apply until a change takes effect.

  • A higher price limit. Raising the home price limit for what the budget calls optional mortgage insurance from $1 million to $1.5 million. The $1 million limit is the one the regulations set for insuring mortgages with 20% or more down.
  • Longer amortizations. Allowing 30-year amortizations on those mortgages when at least one borrower is a first-time buyer or the home is newly built.
  • Rate information. Regulations to have the Bank of Canada publish more information on insured mortgage rates, and a planned consultation on making prepayment penalties on insured mortgages easier to understand and compare.

Questions buyers often ask me

 

What does insurable mean on a mortgage offer?

Your down payment is 20% or more, but the mortgage still meets the rules for insurance, such as a home worth less than $1 million and an amortization of 25 years or less. Your lender can insure it, typically at its own cost, so you usually pay no premium.

Why would putting more down get me a higher rate?

Below 20% down, insurance protects the lender and opens government-backed funding. With 20% or more down, insurance is optional: the lender may pay to insure the mortgage itself or hold it uninsured, which needs more capital. You still borrow less and pay no premium, so compare the total cost.

Can I refinance and keep my insured rate?

Usually not. Taking equity out can't be insured, so the new mortgage is generally priced as uninsured, even if the old one was insured. Borrowing to add a secondary suite can qualify under CMHC's program, which has its own limits.

Will my mortgage stay insured if I switch lenders at renewal?

It can, if you don't borrow more or extend the amortization. Tell the new lender about the insurance you already have. With an insured mortgage, you also don't need to pass the stress test again to switch.

Has the $1 million limit for insurable mortgages changed?

Budget 2026 proposes raising it to $1.5 million and allowing 30-year amortizations when a borrower is a first-time buyer or the home is newly built. Until the regulations change, a home worth $1 million or more with 20% down means an uninsured mortgage.

Shopping for a mortgage? Read how to compare mortgage offers, see whether a mortgage broker or bank suits you, or try my mortgage calculator.

Comparing mortgage offers?

I would be glad to help you plan your purchase and connect you with mortgage professionals who can price each option for you. Call or text 778-834-1706, email silvana@silvanaazurdia.ca or send me a message. Happy to help in English or Spanish.

This article is general information, not financial advice. The details come from CMHC, FCAC, OSFI, the Department of Finance, the Bank of Canada, the federal mortgage insurance regulations and the Budget 2026 documents, and were current at the time of writing; budget measures are proposals until they take effect, and each lender sets its own rates. For FCAC's guide, see how much you need for a down payment.

Silvana Azurdia
Silvana Azurdia

Agent BCFSA 166340

+1(778) 834-1706 | silvana@silvanaazurdia.ca

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message