Posted Rates and Discounted Rates: Why the Difference Matters for Your Penalty

by Silvana Azurdia

If you have a fixed-rate mortgage and might sell, refinance or switch lenders before the term ends, your penalty can depend on a rate you never paid: your lender's posted rate. Here is how posted and discounted rates differ, how the two penalties on a fixed mortgage are worked out, an example comparing two common methods, and what to check before you sign.

The short version

 

Lenders advertise posted rates, and the rate in your contract is often lower: a discounted rate. If you break a closed fixed-rate mortgage early, the penalty is usually the higher of three months' interest or the interest rate differential (IRD), which compares your rate with a current rate for the time left in your term. Some lenders compare your rate with today's posted rate minus the discount you got when you signed; others compare it with the rate they offer today. In my example, with about $477,200 owing and three years left, that choice is the difference between a penalty of about $7,160 and about $14,320. Before you sign, read the prepayment clause and ask which method applies. Before you break, ask for the penalty in writing.

Posted rates and the rate in your contract

 

The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) explains that the rates lenders advertise for each term are posted rates, and if your rate is lower, it's a discounted rate. The gap is your discount: sign at 4.5% when the posted five-year rate is 6.5%, and your discount is 2 percentage points.

The Bank of Canada publishes the most typical posted rates at the six largest banks every week, and separately the rates banks charge on new mortgage lending. In its figures, the typical posted five-year rate has sat well above the rate charged on new fixed mortgages of five years or more. For what moves fixed rates in the first place, see How Fixed Mortgage Rates Are Set.

Your discount sets your payment when you sign. Some lenders use it again if you break the mortgage.

The two penalties on a fixed-rate mortgage

 

FCAC says you may owe a prepayment penalty if you pay more than your contract allows, break it, transfer to another lender or pay off the mortgage before the term ends, including when you sell. On a fixed rate, it is usually the higher of:

  • Three months' interest. Lenders' published formulas take the amount you prepay, multiply it by your annual rate and divide by four.
  • The interest rate differential. The gap between your rate and a comparison rate for the time left in your term, applied to the amount you prepay for the months remaining. FCAC says lenders usually use it when your rate is higher than current rates and you signed less than five years ago.

An open mortgage can be paid off without a penalty, though FCAC notes open rates are typically higher. On a variable-rate mortgage, lenders' published terms usually set the penalty at three months' interest. For an individual borrower with a term longer than five years, the federal Interest Act limits it to three months' interest once five years have passed. You may also pay an administration or discharge fee.

Two ways to work out the IRD

 

FCAC explains that the lender works out the interest left on your term at two rates and charges the difference. Lenders' published terms choose those rates in two broad ways:

  • The contract-rate method. Your contract rate is compared with the rate the lender offers today on a similar mortgage with a term close to the time left, with no discount adjustment.
  • The posted-rate method. The comparison rate is the lender's current posted rate for the term closest to the time left, minus the discount you got when you signed.

Details vary too. Lenders pick the comparison term in different ways, and some discount the IRD to today's value, so the charge is a little lower than the simple formula gives. FCAC's guidance asks federally regulated lenders to disclose how they round the time left and the posted rate or discount used.

An example: the same mortgage, two methods

 

Here is an example with assumed rates, not anyone's offer. Two years ago you took a $500,000 mortgage over 25 years with a five-year fixed term at 4.5%, when the lender's posted five-year rate was 6.5%: a 2-point discount. Your payment is about $2,767 a month, and you now owe about $477,200 with 36 months left. Rates have since fallen: the posted three-year rate is 5.5%, and three-year mortgages are being offered at 4%.

  • Three months' interest: about $5,370.
  • Contract-rate method: 4.5% minus 4% is 0.5 points. Over three years, the IRD is about $7,160.
  • Posted-rate method: 5.5% minus your 2-point discount gives 3.5%, a gap of 1 point. The IRD is about $14,320.

You pay the higher figure, so the penalty is about $7,160 under one method and about $14,320 under the other. The posted-rate method subtracted a 2-point discount from a posted rate only 1.5 points above the rate on offer, so its comparison rate, 3.5%, fell below the 4% actually available. These figures use the simple formula FCAC shows, before any discounting to today's value.

Ways to reduce or avoid the penalty

 
  • Use your prepayment privileges. Closed mortgages commonly let you prepay 10% to 20% of the original amount each year without a penalty, and FCAC notes unused room usually doesn't carry over. If you can prepay before you break, the penalty is figured on a smaller balance: in the example, a $50,000 prepayment (10% of the original amount) cuts the posted-rate IRD by $1,500. Some lenders restrict prepayments close to the date you break.
  • Port the mortgage. If you are buying another home, porting takes your rate, terms and conditions with you instead of breaking the contract. I compare the options in Porting, Blending or Breaking.
  • Wait if you can. FCAC suggests waiting until the end of your term to prepay when the penalty would be large. At maturity, you can pay off or move the mortgage without one.
  • Run the numbers. If you are breaking for a lower rate, compare the penalty and fees with the interest you would save; a mortgage professional can run both for you.

What to check before you sign

 

Compare penalties before you choose a lender, not when you need to break. With a bank or federal credit union, prepayment privileges and penalties must appear in an information box at the start of your agreement, and the lender must explain how the penalty is calculated and what factors it uses. Ask:

  • Which rates go into the IRD: my contract rate or the posted rate, and today's posted rate with or without my discount?
  • How is the comparison term chosen, and is the IRD discounted to today's value?
  • Where are my discount and the posted rate shown in my documents?
  • What can I prepay each year without a penalty, and can I use it right before I break?
  • Is the mortgage portable, how long do I have to buy the next home, and how is extra borrowing priced?

If you might sell within a few years, weigh these answers alongside the rate. I cover the rest of the fine print in Comparing Mortgage Offers and term lengths in Choosing a Mortgage Term.

Getting your penalty in writing

 

Banks that belong to the Canadian Bankers Association have agreed to a code of conduct on prepayment information. Under it, they post penalty calculators online, offer a toll-free line with staff who can answer prepayment questions, and give you a written statement of your penalty on request. Your annual statement also shows what you can prepay each year without a charge and explains how the charge is calculated.

Ask for the figure in writing, ask how long it is valid, and ask again close to your completion or switch date, since it changes with rates and your balance. With a provincially regulated credit union or another lender, read the prepayment section of your agreement and ask the same questions.

Questions borrowers often ask me

 

Why would my penalty be more than three months' interest?

Because the IRD came out higher. That usually happens when rates have fallen since you signed and years are left in a fixed term. The method matters too: a posted rate minus your original discount can sit below the rates lenders are actually offering.

What is a posted rate?

It's the rate a lender advertises for each term. The rate in your contract may be lower, and the gap is your discount. The Bank of Canada tracks the most typical posted rates at the six largest banks each week.

Can I find out my penalty before I decide?

Yes. Banks that belong to the Canadian Bankers Association give you a written statement of the penalty on request, and offer online calculators and a toll-free line. Ask how long the figure is valid, since it changes as rates and your balance change.

Is the penalty different on a variable-rate mortgage?

Usually it's three months' interest, according to lenders' published terms, rather than the higher of three months' interest or an IRD. The prepayment clause in your own agreement is what applies to you.

Does a longer term mean a bigger penalty?

It can in the first five years, since more time is left for the IRD. For an individual borrower, once five years have passed on a term longer than five years, the Interest Act limits the penalty to three months' interest.

Planning a sale or a refinance? Read about renewing your mortgage before your term ends and refinancing your mortgage in BC, or try my mortgage calculator.

Thinking of selling or refinancing before your term ends?

I would be glad to help you plan the timing of your sale or purchase around your mortgage and connect you with mortgage professionals who can run your numbers. Call or text 778-834-1706, email silvana@silvanaazurdia.ca or send me a message. Happy to help in English or Spanish.

This article is general information, not financial advice. The details come from FCAC, the Bank of Canada, the federal Interest Act, the federal code of conduct on mortgage prepayment information and lenders' published prepayment terms, and were current at the time of writing; your mortgage agreement sets out how your own penalty is calculated. For FCAC's guide, see mortgage prepayment penalties.

Silvana Azurdia
Silvana Azurdia

Agent BCFSA 166340

+1(778) 834-1706 | silvana@silvanaazurdia.ca

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message